Checkatrade alternative: what do trades use instead?
Most Checkatrade alternatives are another site with another fee. Swap one for the next and you still pay, you're still tied in, and other trades still get the same customer. Some routes cost nothing to set up. The one that's yours is your own website and Google profile, your page on Google Maps.
Round and round
Leave one site, join the next. A new fee, new rules, a new page of reviews. Bloody pointless.
Rated People has closed and sends its jobs to Checkatrade. So that one's off the list.
Eight options, side by side
Here's what each one charges, how long it ties you in, and who else gets the same customer. Google Local Services Ads are ads on Google where you pay when a customer gets in touch.
| Option | How you pay | How long you're tied in | Do other trades get the same customer? |
|---|---|---|---|
| TrustATrader | A yearly fee, paid at the start. The price isn't public | 12 months. You can't leave early. It doesn't start again on its own | Yes. At most 10 firms per trade in each area |
| MyBuilder | A fee each time your details go to a customer, win or lose. The amounts aren't public | No set time | Yes. How many isn't public |
| Bark | You buy credits at £1.80 each | Credits run out after 3 months. A credit pack plan lasts at most 12 months, then carries on unless you cancel | Yes. At most 5 responses per customer |
| MyJobQuote | Credits, by plan or as you go. The prices aren't public | Month by month. 3 days' warning to leave | Yes. At most 3 trades per job |
| Which? Trusted Traders | £248 to be checked, then from £69 a month | No set time. 3 months' warning to leave | It sends no jobs. Customers search and open your page |
| Buy With Confidence | £165 to apply, then £305 a year, both plus VAT. For 5 staff or fewer | Their pages don't say | A list run by the council's Trading Standards. Nearest first. It sends no jobs |
| Google Local Services Ads | Each time a real customer calls or messages you. Google publishes no price | You set a budget and can change it | Other firms paying for ads can show up beside you |
| Your own website and Google profile | The profile costs nothing. You pay once to build the website | You're not tied in to anyone | No. The customer finds you |
We build websites and get trades higher up on Google ourselves, so we're not neutral.
The ones that cost nothing
Some routes cost nothing to set up. Each has a limit.
Google Business Profile
Your page on Google Search and Maps, with photos, hours, your number and reviews.
It works when you keep it filled in.
Nextdoor
A business page and posts to your neighbours.
It reaches people on Nextdoor.
Facebook
A Page and the local groups.
It reaches people who follow you or sit in the same groups.
Yell and FreeIndex
Your business page, with reviews.
Both sell paid extras.
Word of mouth
Trades say most of their work comes from it.
It reaches as far as the people who know you.
On one you chase leads, on the other leads chase you.
On every site in the table, other trades are in front of the same customer. On the ones that send jobs, you race to ring first.
We've done the ringing on Bark, Checkatrade and MyBuilder. You ring fast. You try to be one of the first few. Most calls go nowhere, which is crap.
On your own website and Google profile, the customer finds you.
You chase
They come to you
Your website is where it all lands
Your website is the machine. Everything you do at no cost points to it. Someone searches Google. Someone finds your profile on Maps. A friend passes your name on. A customer leaves a review. Someone sees your Facebook or Nextdoor page. They all end up on your website. Then your phone rings.
We work in this order. The website. Your Google profile after it. SEO last, which means getting Google to show you higher when someone searches for your trade.
No lock-in, and the price
- Pay monthly. Tell us a month before you go and you're gone. Everything we built is still yours.
- If Google's own numbers for you haven't improved after 90 days, your monthly fees come back. The website build isn't refunded.
SEO from 450 a month
Questions
What's better, Checkatrade or TrustATrader?
TrustATrader is a yearly fee paid at the start, and you can't leave early. Checkatrade plans that send jobs run 12 months and start again on their own. Neither publishes how many jobs it sends.
What are some similar websites to Checkatrade?
TrustATrader, MyBuilder, Bark and MyJobQuote. Which? Trusted Traders and Buy With Confidence check you first, then list you. Rated People has closed.
What is the best website for tradesmen in the UK?
Your own. It carries your jobs, your number and your reviews, and no other firm's fee.
Send Arthur your website
Send your website, or just your business name. He tells you straight where you stand on Google.